Guide

Choosing the right pond liner material

EPDM and Butyl rubber — both are excellent materials for a box-welded liner. Here's how they differ and how to choose.

The two materials we use

All our box-welded pond liners are manufactured in EPDM (ethylene propylene diene monomer) or Butyl rubber. Both are available in 0.75mm standard grade and 1.0mm heavy duty, both carry a 25-year guarantee, and both are safe for fish and aquatic plants.

EPDM

  • Excellent UV and ozone resistance
  • Highly flexible, even at low temperatures
  • Lightweight and easy to handle on site
  • Available in 0.75mm standard and 1.0mm heavy duty

Butyl rubber

  • Extremely flexible and puncture-resistant
  • Performs particularly well in very cold climates
  • Long track record in pond construction
  • Available in 0.75mm standard and 1.0mm heavy duty

Which should you choose?

For the vast majority of ponds — garden ponds, koi ponds, natural swimming pools and raised features — either material performs equally well. The 0.75mm grade suits most domestic installations; the 1.0mm heavy duty is recommended for koi ponds, larger builds, or anywhere additional robustness is valued.

If you are unsure which is right for your project, just mention it in your quote request and we will recommend based on your pond type, size and location. If you are comparing a box-welded liner against a flat sheet liner, the more important consideration is construction method, not material.

For application-specific material recommendations, see our koi pond liner page (where we recommend 1.0mm heavy duty) and our natural swimming pool liner page.

Frequently asked questions

Both EPDM and Butyl rubber are excellent options for box-welded pond liners — durable, fish-safe and weldable to precise tolerances. If you are not sure which would be best for your project, we are happy to advise.

Yes. Both EPDM and Butyl rubber are inert once installed and completely safe for fish and aquatic plants.

Both materials offer excellent longevity under a 25-year guarantee. EPDM is slightly more flexible at very low temperatures; Butyl rubber is extremely puncture-resistant. For most garden pond applications, either is a sound long-term choice.

Ready to get a quote?

Tell us your dimensions — we'll send a drawing and a price, same working day.

Get a free quote →
Chat with us